| 1 | | Dondzila, Nick | JR | Loyola-New Orleans | 49.01m | 160' 9.75" | 10 | | 49.01 | 48.69 | FOUL | 47.58 | 46.53 | FOUL |
|
| 2 | | Walters, Caleb | FR | Belhaven | 47.96m | 157' 4.50" | 8 | | 45.35 | 46.20 | 47.96 | FOUL | 45.24 | 46.64 |
|
| 3 | | Parker, Anthony | JR | Loyola-New Orleans | 43.99m | 144' 4.25" | 6 | | 43.99 | FOUL | 42.31 | FOUL | 43.87 | 43.95 |
|
| 4 | | Nevils, Danny | SO | Mobile | 43.47m | 142' 7.75" | 5 | | 42.59 | 40.00 | FOUL | FOUL | 43.47 | 42.54 |
|
| 5 | | Loper, Braxton | FR | Belhaven | 36.45m | 119' 7.25" | 4 | | 35.05 | FOUL | FOUL | 32.68 | 35.36 | 36.45 |
|
| 6 | | Berry, Walker | FR | Mobile | 35.12m | 115' 3" | 3 | | FOUL | FOUL | 35.12 | 33.65 | FOUL | FOUL |
|
| 7 | | Underwood, Kyle | SO | William Carey | 33.52m | 110' 0" | 2 | | FOUL | FOUL | 29.83 | 33.52 | 31.64 | PASS |
|
