| Lane | Athlete | Yr | Team | Seed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | McElhiney, Sam | Gold | 4:23.0h | |
| 2 | Docherty, Kevin | Black | 4:16.0h | |
| 3 | Price-Mile, Brook | Gold | 4:19.0h | |
| 4 | Gregorio, Anthony | Black | 4:20.0h | |
| 5 | Butler, Matt | Gold | 4:15.0h | |
| 6 | Hart, Michael | Black | 4:25.0h | |
| 7 | Sindelar, Josh | Gold | 4:24.0h | |
| 8 | Larson, Ryan | Gold | 4:24.0h | |
| 9 | Simmons, Connor | Black | 4:24.0h |